Separate prices and quantities
Gross domestic product measures final production within the United States. Nominal GDP expresses that production at current prices. It can increase because more is produced, because prices rise, or because both occur. Its dollar value alone does not isolate a change in quantities.
Real GDP uses price-adjusted, chain-type quantity measurement to separate changes in production from changes in prices. BEA expresses the level in chained dollars with a stated reference year. The reference year is metadata; it can change during updates and should remain in a downloaded dataset.
Do not add chained-dollar components
Chain-type measures update relative price weights over time. Their chained-dollar components generally do not sum exactly to the total outside the reference-year setting. Adding real consumption, investment and other chained-dollar components is therefore not a valid general method for recreating real GDP.
To describe how a component affects GDP growth, use the producer’s published contributions or a validated method. A component’s own growth rate is not its contribution in percentage points. This site does not create component contribution estimates by casually adding or multiplying incompatible levels.
Levels and growth rates
A quarterly GDP level is commonly presented at a seasonally adjusted annual rate. That level is not the number of dollars produced only during the quarter. Quarterly annualized growth compounds the quarter-to-quarter level ratio over four quarters; it is distinct from nonannualized quarterly change and year-over-year growth.
Advance, second and third estimates can all be followed by further revisions. The third estimate is not permanently final. For research, retain the observation quarter, nominal or real basis, source publication date, transformation and site snapshot. A file fetched today can contain estimates published earlier, so acquisition and publication must remain separate.
A short history of the measures
Official U.S. national income estimates began in the 1930s, when the Commerce Department delivered estimates to Congress in 1934 building on work by economist Simon Kuznets. For decades, gross national product (GNP) was the headline measure. BEA shifted its featured measure to GDP in 1991, emphasizing production within U.S. borders rather than production by U.S. residents wherever located. GNP is still published, but GDP became the standard measure for comparisons with other countries.
Real output was once measured in constant dollars of a single fixed base year. That method gave stale weights to goods whose relative prices had changed sharply, such as computers. In its 1996 comprehensive revision, BEA adopted chain-type measures as the featured real estimates, expressed in chained dollars. The change reduced the bias from fixed weights and explains why chained-dollar components do not add up exactly.
How the two measures are used
Real GDP is the usual measure for questions about economic growth, recessions and productivity, because it removes the effect of price changes. Nominal GDP is the better denominator for ratios built from current-dollar values, such as federal debt or a deficit as a share of GDP. Dividing a nominal amount by real GDP mixes valuation bases and distorts the ratio.
BEA also publishes price measures for GDP, including a chain-type price index and an implicit price deflator, which equals nominal GDP divided by real GDP times 100. These measures cover prices of everything produced domestically, including investment goods and government purchases. They differ from consumer price measures and are not substitutes for the CPI when the question concerns household purchases.
Common reporting errors
A frequent error is describing growth in nominal GDP as economic growth without noting that part of it reflects higher prices. If nominal GDP rises 6% while prices rise 4%, real output grows only about 2%. Another error is to quote a real GDP level in chained dollars without its reference year, or to compare levels from datasets that use different reference years.
A third error is to divide a nominal amount from one table by a real amount from another and present the result as a meaningful ratio. A careful citation includes the basis, unit, adjustment and table: for example, “Real GDP, chained 2017 dollars, seasonally adjusted annual rate, BEA NIPA Table 1.1.6,” with the reference year written as it appears in the downloaded file.
Worked example: separating price and quantity
Suppose a hypothetical economy’s nominal GDP rises from $20,000 billion to $21,000 billion over a year, while its GDP price index rises from 100.0 to 103.0. This simplified example deflates the total with one index, unlike BEA’s chain-type method.
- Nominal growth: 21,000 ÷ 20,000 = 1.05, so current-dollar output rose 5.0%.
- Price growth: 103.0 ÷ 100.0 = 1.03, so prices rose 3.0%.
- Real growth: 1.05 ÷ 1.03 ≈ 1.01942, so the volume of output rose about 1.94%.
- Real level in starting-period prices: 21,000 ÷ 1.03 ≈ $20,388 billion, which equals 20,000 × 1.01942 (rounded).
- The shortcut 5.0 − 3.0 = 2.0% overstates real growth by about 0.06 percentage point here, and the error grows when inflation and growth rates are larger.
Takeaway: Nominal growth combines price and quantity change. Dividing growth ratios, not subtracting rates, isolates the quantity change.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between nominal and real GDP?
Nominal GDP values output at the prices of the period in which it is produced, so it rises with both production and prices. Real GDP removes the effect of price changes, so it tracks changes in the volume of production. Economic growth rates reported in the news are normally based on real GDP.
What does “chained dollars” mean?
Chained dollars express real GDP and its components in the dollar values of a stated reference year, derived from chain-type quantity indexes that update price weights over time. BEA adopted this approach in its 1996 comprehensive revision. Chained-dollar components generally do not sum exactly to the total, so they should not be added together.
What is the GDP deflator?
The implicit price deflator for GDP equals nominal GDP divided by real GDP, multiplied by 100. It reflects prices of all domestic production, including business investment and government purchases. BEA also publishes a chain-type GDP price index. Both differ in scope from consumer price measures such as the CPI and the PCE price index.
Should debt-to-GDP ratios use nominal or real GDP?
Use nominal GDP. Debt and deficits are measured in current dollars, so the denominator should be in current dollars for the same period. Dividing a current-dollar amount by real GDP in chained dollars mixes valuation bases and produces a ratio that drifts with the price level.